News | Port St. Lucie

Safest Neighborhoods in Port St. Lucie, FL: Top Areas for 2025

Sunny suburban street in one of Port St. Lucie's safest neighborhoods

Port St. Lucie, FL, is widely recognized for its vibrant lifestyle, family-friendly amenities, and overall safety, making it an attractive city for residents and visitors alike. Known for its active outdoor scene and golf attractions such as PGA Village, Port St. Lucie maintains a commendable safety rating compared to other cities in Florida.

Understanding Safety in Port St. Lucie

According to CrimeGrade.org, Port St. Lucie has earned an overall safety grade of B+, indicating it is safer than approximately 73% of U.S. cities. The likelihood of experiencing violent crime in Port St. Lucie is relatively low, with a rate of about 1 in 868 people. Property crimes, although more common, occur at a rate of 1 in 133, significantly lower than Florida’s average of 1 in 64.

Top Safest Neighborhoods in Port St. Lucie, FL

PGA Village/Carlton

PGA Village/Carlton is recognized as one of Florida’s most upscale and secure neighborhoods. Primarily rural, this area attracts seasonal residents, retirees, and families due to its walkable design and reduced traffic congestion. The neighborhood’s layout contributes to fewer car accidents, although pedestrians should remain vigilant due to increased foot traffic. The area is also patrolled by the Port St. Lucie Police Department, which maintains a strong community policing presence.

Fountainview

Fountainview offers a blend of single-family homes and apartment complexes, including high-rise buildings with scenic views. Known for its historic charm and classic Florida architecture, Fountainview maintains a notably low crime rate, making it particularly attractive to retirees seeking a secure living environment. The neighborhood is also near several healthcare facilities, including HCA Florida St. Lucie Hospital, which enhances its appeal to older adults.

North St. James/St. Andrews Park

North St. James/St. Andrews Park is a suburban community boasting primarily newer single-family homes built around or after 2000. This affluent neighborhood attracts educated professionals and executives, with a significant presence of active military personnel, further enhancing its sense of security. The area benefits from proximity to Florida Atlantic University’s Treasure Coast campus, contributing to its professional and academic environment.

Gaitlin Pines

Gaitlin Pines, located on Port St. Lucie’s west side, predominantly features occupied single-family homes. Known for its walkability, this neighborhood is popular among college students and is considered one of Florida’s top college-friendly communities. It is also served by St. Lucie Public Schools, which supports families with school-aged children.

Crime Comparison with Nearby Cities

When compared to neighboring cities, Port St. Lucie stands out positively. Nearby Jensen Beach received a safety grade of D+, Hutchinson Island South earned an F, and Ocean Breeze Park was rated C. These comparisons highlight Port St. Lucie’s relatively safe environment. For more detailed regional crime statistics, refer to the Florida Department of Law Enforcement.

Safety Tips for Residents and Visitors

  • Stay vigilant while walking, especially in high pedestrian traffic areas.
  • Choose neighborhoods with lower crime rates for residence or extended stays.
  • Be cautious on roads, particularly in areas with seasonal visitors unfamiliar with local traffic patterns.
  • Report suspicious activities to local authorities promptly through the Port St. Lucie Police Department.

Frequently Asked Questions About Safest Neighborhoods in Port St. Lucie, FL

What is the safest neighborhood in Port St. Lucie?

PGA Village/Carlton is considered one of the safest neighborhoods in Port St. Lucie, known for its low crime rates and upscale community.

Are retirement communities in Port St. Lucie safe?

Yes, retirement communities like Fountainview are known for their safety, low crime rates, and peaceful environments, ideal for seniors.

How much safer is Port St. Lucie compared to nearby cities?

Port St. Lucie is significantly safer, earning a B+ rating compared to nearby cities like Jensen Beach (D+) and Hutchinson Island South (F).

Can you find safe neighborhoods near PGA Village?

Yes, neighborhoods near PGA Village, such as Carlton, are among the safest areas in Port St. Lucie, attracting families and retirees.

Where are the safest areas for college students in PSL?

Gaitlin Pines is highly recommended for college students due to its safety, walkability, and community-focused atmosphere.

Interested in learning more about the safest neighborhoods in Port St. Lucie? Download our FREE guide.

Port St Lucie Talks

Related News

Video News St. Lucie County

Local News

Crime & Public Safety

Politics & Government

Real Estate & Housing

Aerial view of luxury beachfront mansion at 433 S. Beach Road, Jupiter Island, Florida

Florida Real Estate Most Expensive Home Sales April 2025

Engineer inspecting Florida condo building as part of milestone safety report requirements.

Milestone Inspection Report in Florida: Key Facts for Condo Owners

Diamond Sands oceanfront estate with ocean and Intracoastal views in Jensen Beach

Diamond Sands Oceanfront Estate Auction Set for Jensen Beach

Luxury $24.3M beachfront home with palm-lined pool on Jupiter Island

Florida Luxury Home Sales: Top Treasure Coast Deals in March

Aerial photo of Port St. Lucie housing developments and suburban expansion

Affordable Housing Port St. Lucie Remains Critical Issue

Aerial view of residential homes in St. Lucie County, Florida

Affordable Housing St. Lucie County: Essential Workers in Need

VIRAL News

Transportation & Infrastructure