Jury selection is underway in the capital murder trial of Jose Antonio Soto Escalera, who is accused of killing Tania Wise and her unborn son in St. Lucie County in 2018. This high-profile case has drawn attention across the Treasure Coast due to the severity of the charges and the details of the investigation, reminiscent of other tragic incidents such as the Eriese Tisdale deputy murder case that also shook the community.

Capital Murder Trial for Jose Antonio Soto Escalera in St. Lucie County

The trial for Jose Antonio Soto Escalera, 48, of Port St. Lucie, began with jury selection in early September 2025. Escalera faces two counts of first-degree murder: one for the death of Tania Wise, 23, and another for the killing of her unborn child. If convicted, Escalera could receive either a death sentence or life in prison without the possibility of parole.

Background of the Case: The Deaths of Tania Wise and Her Unborn Son

On August 24, 2018, the body of Tania Wise, who was eight months pregnant, was discovered face-down in a ditch along Russo Road near Johnston Road. This rural area in northwest St. Lucie County became the focus of a complex homicide investigation. Wise was scheduled to have a cesarean section the week after her death.

According to the St. Lucie County Sheriff’s Office, Wise suffered blunt force trauma to the back of her head, skull fractures, and a fatal throat wound. The unborn child, later identified as Josiah Wise, also died as a result of the attack.

Investigation Links Escalera to the Murders

Detectives quickly began interviewing Wise’s friends, family, and acquaintances. Multiple witnesses reported that Escalera was upset about Wise’s pregnancy and had discussed buying an untraceable gun. Some witnesses stated that Wise had told them Escalera gave her $500 for an abortion, which she did not obtain. Instead, Wise reportedly kept the money, further angering Escalera.

Key Evidence: DNA, Surveillance, and Cellphone Data

Investigators used a combination of digital forensics and witness statements to build their case. Surveillance footage captured a Dodge Ram truck matching Escalera’s on Wise’s street on the evening of August 23, 2018. Cellphone records placed Escalera near both Wise’s home and the area where her body was found later that night.

DNA evidence confirmed that Escalera was the father of Wise’s unborn child. During interviews, Escalera denied having a sexual relationship with Wise but provided a DNA sample that contradicted his statement. The use of advanced investigative techniques in this case is similar to those employed in other recent Port St. Lucie police investigations into traveling criminal activity throughout the region.

Jury Selection Process in the Capital Murder Trial

For this death penalty case, Circuit Judge Lawrence Mirman ordered court clerks to summon 400 prospective jurors. The selection process involves extensive questioning about Florida death penalty statute, with jurors interviewed in groups of 50. The goal is to seat a panel of 12 jurors plus alternates by September 8, 2025.

• Potential jurors are questioned about their views on capital punishment.
• The trial is expected to last up to two weeks.
• If convicted, the same jury will decide between a death sentence or life imprisonment.

Aggravating and Mitigating Factors in Sentencing

Prosecutors have identified several aggravating circumstances, including:

• The crime was especially heinous, atrocious, or cruel.
• The victim was less than 12 years old (the unborn child).
• The crime was committed in a cold, calculated, and premeditated manner.
• The murder was for pecuniary gain.
• Escalera’s prior felony convictions involving violence.

The defense may present mitigating factors, such as Escalera’s mental health or personal history. Under Florida law, a supermajority of at least 8 out of 12 jurors must recommend the death penalty for it to be imposed.

Community Impact and Ongoing Legal Proceedings

The deaths of Tania Wise and her unborn son have had a significant impact on the St. Lucie County community. The case has been closely followed due to its tragic details and the extensive investigation led by the St. Lucie County Sheriff’s Office. Escalera has remained in the St. Lucie County Jail since his arrest in September 2018, awaiting trial. Recent high-profile incidents, such as a St. Lucie County deputy’s arrest for a road rage burglary incident, have only heightened public scrutiny of law enforcement and justice proceedings in the area.

Timeline of Key Events

• August 24, 2018: Tania Wise and her unborn son found deceased in northwest St. Lucie County.
• September 21, 2018: Jose Antonio Soto Escalera arrested and charged with two counts of first-degree murder.
• September 2025: Jury selection begins for Escalera’s capital murder trial.

Frequently Asked Questions About the Jose Antonio Soto Escalera Capital Murder Trial

What is the Jose Antonio Soto Escalera capital murder trial about?

This trial involves Jose Antonio Soto Escalera, who is accused of killing Tania Wise and her unborn son in St. Lucie County in 2018. He faces two counts of first-degree murder and could receive the death penalty or life in prison if convicted.

How long has Escalera been in jail awaiting trial?

Escalera has been held in the St. Lucie County Jail since his arrest in September 2018, awaiting the start of his capital murder trial.

Are there aggravating factors in this St. Lucie County murder case?

Yes, prosecutors have identified several aggravating factors, including the cruelty of the crime, the age of the victims, and evidence of premeditation. These factors are considered during sentencing if Escalera is convicted.

Can you explain how the jury selection works for a death penalty trial in Florida?

Jury selection involves summoning a large pool of potential jurors and questioning them about their views on the death penalty. In this case, 400 prospective jurors are being interviewed to find 12 jurors and alternates who can serve impartially.

Where are the trial proceedings taking place?

The trial is being held in St. Lucie County, with proceedings overseen by Circuit Judge Lawrence Mirman. The case is followed closely by the Port St. Lucie and Treasure Coast communities.

Port St Lucie Talks