Homicide Suspect Behind Bars on Treasure Coast

The recent homicide investigation in St. Lucie County has led to the arrest of Carlos Tito Caban, a 51-year-old sex offender, who is now in custody on charges related to probation violations. Although he has not been formally charged with the homicide of Toni Lynn Marie Trabb, authorities have identified him as the sole suspect in her death, which occurred at a hotel on South U.S. 1.

Details of the Homicide Investigation in St. Lucie County

On March 24, 2025, Trabb was found dead in a room at the Best Western Hotels & Resorts located in the 7900 block of South U.S. 1. Hotel staff discovered her body during routine cleaning, prompting an immediate response from rescue and sheriff’s officials. The investigation quickly focused on Caban, who was linked to the case after authorities in Tifton, Georgia, stopped him in Trabb’s vehicle.

Link Between Port St. Lucie and Georgia

Authorities confirmed that Caban was located in Georgia with another woman, in Trabb’s vehicle, about 370 miles from Port St. Lucie. Lt. Andrew Bolonka, spokesperson for the St. Lucie County Sheriff’s Office, explained that the woman traveling with Caban was not identified but had met him in the Orlando area. Caban reportedly told her he was headed to New York, and she asked to join him, leading to their joint travel.

Background of Carlos Tito Caban

Caban has a criminal history related to sexual offenses. According to the Florida Department of Law Enforcement, he was convicted in January 2021 in Indian River County of sexual battery by an adult on an adult victim with aggravating circumstances. He was released from prison in 2023 and has been under supervision since then.

Recent Arrests and Probation Violations

On April 5, 2025, Caban was arrested at the St. Lucie County Jail on a felony charge for failure to report vacating his residence, a violation of sex offender registration laws. Later, on April 14, he was also taken into custody in Indian River County Criminal Records on a probation violation. Despite these arrests, authorities have not linked him directly to Trabb’s death.

Ongoing Investigation and Community Impact

The St. Lucie County Sheriff’s Office continues to investigate the circumstances surrounding Trabb’s death. The case has raised concerns within the local community about safety and the monitoring of sex offenders. Officials emphasize that Caban remains a suspect, but formal charges related to homicide are pending further evidence.

Related Incidents on the Treasure Coast

In addition to this homicide, the Treasure Coast has seen other recent law enforcement activities, including a fatal crash in St. Lucie County and arrests related to fraud and theft at local auto dealerships. These incidents highlight ongoing public safety efforts in the region.

Location

St. Lucie County

Frequently Asked Questions About Homicide Suspect in Treasure Coast

What is known about the homicide suspect in Port St. Lucie?

The suspect, Carlos Tito Caban, is a 51-year-old sex offender who is currently in custody on probation violation charges. Authorities have identified him as the only suspect in the March homicide of Toni Lynn Marie Trabb but have not yet charged him with the crime. For more details, see the St. Lucie County homicide investigation identifying the suspect.

How much time has Caban spent in prison?

Caban was convicted in January 2021 of sexual battery and was released from prison in 2023. He has been under supervision since then and is now facing new charges related to his probation violations.

Are there other recent crimes involving Caban?

Yes, Caban was arrested in April 2025 for failing to report his residence as a sex offender. He was also detained in Indian River County for a probation violation, but he has not been charged with the homicide of Trabb.

Where are the ongoing investigations focused?

The investigation is focused on the circumstances of Trabb’s death at the hotel, Caban’s whereabouts, and his potential involvement. Authorities are also monitoring his movements following his recent arrests. For updates from local law enforcement, visit the Port St. Lucie Police Department.

For more updates on law enforcement activities and community safety in Port St. Lucie, stay tuned to PortStLucieTalks.com.

[Discover detailed information about local 55+ communities and active adult options in Port St. Lucie.] Download our FREE guide.