Fort Pierce residents are voicing strong concerns over a massive redevelopment plan on Hutchinson Island that could dramatically alter the city’s skyline and coastline. The controversial project, proposed at the Causeway Cove Marina, includes the construction of five high-rise buildings, one reaching 17 stories and over 180 feet tall, significantly exceeding current city height restrictions.
Fort Pierce Redevelopment Proposal Sparks Community Debate
The proposed development by G Flash G.P. Inc. aims to transform the marina area by adding apartments, condominiums, a hotel, and commercial spaces. Residents such as Karen Cashen have openly criticized the project, labeling it an “eyesore” that doesn’t align with the character and charm of Fort Pierce and Hutchinson Island.
“It’s going to be an eyesore,” Cashen stated during a recent city meeting. “It’s not in line with what Fort Pierce, Hutchinson Island is all about.” This debate comes at a time when the city is already facing other significant decisions, such as the recent move to postpone the selection of a new city manager amid applicant reviews.
Impact of Florida’s Live Local Act on Fort Pierce Development
The controversy surrounding the project is heightened by Florida’s Live Local Act, passed in 2023. This state law allows developers to bypass local height and density restrictions if they allocate at least 40% of the development for affordable housing. According to city officials, this leaves them with limited options to oppose or modify the project.
Fort Pierce Commissioner Michael Broderick expressed frustration at a recent commission meeting, acknowledging the city’s limited power to influence the development under current state laws.
“There is nothing this body can do about it,” Broderick said. “We can criticize all we want, but it falls on deaf ears because it goes nowhere.” Meanwhile, Fort Pierce has also recently addressed other community concerns, like implementing paid parking plans at local beach parks, which have sparked similar discussions among residents.
Residents Fear Increased Traffic and Infrastructure Strain
Local residents are particularly worried about the project’s potential impact on traffic congestion and infrastructure. Resident Laurie Partlo highlighted existing traffic issues, especially on Seaway Drive and the nearby bridge.
“Even in the off-season, traffic on the bridge and on Seaway Drive is pretty heavy,” Partlo noted. “Then you throw all these people in there, and it’s going to become even worse.”
Supporters Cite Economic Benefits and Job Creation
Despite the criticism, some community members see potential benefits from the redevelopment. Harold Hayes, General Manager at Causeway Cove Marina, believes the project could bring significant economic advantages and job opportunities to Fort Pierce.
“Look realistically into what’s going on and the money that will be generated and the jobs that will be generated,” Hayes said, supporting the proposed changes. Additionally, some residents are optimistic that the revival of other local projects, such as the King’s Landing redevelopment, signals positive economic momentum for the city.
Next Steps for the Hutchinson Island Redevelopment Project
Moving forward, developers are required to submit detailed studies addressing traffic patterns, environmental impacts, and drainage concerns. These reports will provide further information on the project’s feasibility and potential effects on the local community.
While the city and developers have declined to provide additional comments at this stage, residents remain actively engaged and vocal about their concerns, continuing to monitor developments closely.
Frequently Asked Questions About Fort Pierce Redevelopment
What is the Fort Pierce redevelopment project?
The Fort Pierce redevelopment project is a proposed construction plan at Causeway Cove Marina on Hutchinson Island. It includes five high-rise buildings, with apartments, condos, a hotel, and commercial spaces.
How much taller is the proposed building compared to Fort Pierce height limits?
The tallest proposed building is over 180 feet high, more than four times the current height limit allowed in Fort Pierce on Hutchinson Island.
Are there any benefits to the Hutchinson Island redevelopment?
Supporters say the redevelopment could create jobs and boost the local economy. It may also provide more affordable housing options due to the Live Local Act.
Can residents stop the redevelopment on Hutchinson Island?
Due to Florida’s Live Local Act, residents and city officials have limited power to stop the project. Developers can bypass local rules if they include affordable housing.
Where exactly is the redevelopment taking place in Fort Pierce?
The redevelopment is planned at Causeway Cove Marina, located on Hutchinson Island, near Seaway Drive and the bridge connecting to mainland Fort Pierce.
Stay informed about retirement living in Port St. Lucie—Download your complimentary guide today.
Port St Lucie Talks
