Four Seasons at Wylder 55+ community in Port St. Lucie by K. Hovnanian Homes featuring resort-style pool, clubhouse, and on-site consultant Dash Hernandez.”

News | Port St. Lucie

Florida Ranks Most Expensive for Homeowners Insurance

Map showing Florida as the most expensive state for homeowners insurance premiums

Florida is now the most expensive state for homeowners insurance, according to a recent analysis by realtor.com. The study found that Florida’s median premiums surpass those of every other state, despite recent legislative efforts to reduce costs. In fact, some insurers are beginning to respond, as seen when Florida Peninsula Insurance proposed a historic rate cut for homeowners, signaling potential shifts in the market.

Florida Homeowners Insurance Costs Lead the Nation

According to realtor.com, Florida tops the national list for highest homeowners insurance premiums. The analysis highlights that more Florida homeowners pay over $4,000 per year for coverage than in any other state. This trend continues even as lawmakers have introduced reforms aimed at stabilizing the property insurance market, and as property insurance companies in Florida see profits surge despite the high costs for consumers.

Median Premiums Remain High

Realtor.com reported that Florida’s median homeowners insurance premiums are the highest in the country. Troves of residents are now paying significantly more than the national average, with many exceeding $4,000 annually for their policies.

Comparison to Other States

The study found that states such as Colorado, Nebraska, and Texas also have high insurance premiums, but none match Florida’s rates. In Texas and Colorado, most homeowners pay between $2,000 and $2,499 per year—substantially less than in Florida. Other states in the top ten for high costs include Kansas, Oklahoma, and Louisiana.

Factors Driving High Insurance Premiums in Florida

Extreme weather is a primary reason for Florida’s expensive homeowners insurance, according to realtor.com. The state’s coastal geography makes it especially vulnerable to hurricanes and flooding, increasing the risk for insurers.

Impact of Disaster Risk

Jake Krimmel, senior economist at realtor.com, stated, “Disaster risk varies widely by geography, with coastal areas obviously susceptible to hurricane-related damage a prime example.” He added that flood risk is not limited to the coast but can affect properties near rivers and floodplains throughout the state.

  • Hurricane risk: Florida’s long coastline increases exposure to hurricanes.
  • Flooding: Both coastal and inland areas face flood threats.
  • Litigation environment: Past legal incentives contributed to higher premiums.

Legislative Efforts to Address Insurance Costs

Florida lawmakers have enacted several reforms in recent years to address rising homeowners insurance premiums. According to the Florida Chamber of Commerce, changes in 2022 and 2023 aimed to reduce frivolous lawsuits and encourage more insurers to enter the market.

New Companies Entering the Market

Mark Wilson, President and CEO of the Florida Chamber of Commerce, stated that 15 new companies have joined Florida’s property insurance market since the legislative changes. These reforms restricted lawsuit incentives that previously led many insurers to raise premiums or exit the state.

Ongoing Challenges

Despite these efforts, Florida continues to lead the nation in homeowners insurance costs. The report notes that residents with mortgages pay about twice as much for insurance as those without, adding further strain to household budgets. For those concerned about future changes, it’s important to stay updated on Florida home insurance rate changes and the upcoming hurricane season. For official information and regulatory updates, consult the Florida Office of Insurance Regulation.

Homeowners Insurance and Housing Affordability

High insurance premiums are affecting housing affordability across Florida. According to realtor.com, insurance costs are now a major factor shaping the ability of residents to buy and maintain homes, especially in the current high-rate, high-priced environment. For industry insights and advocacy, the National Association of Realtors provides valuable resources for both buyers and real estate professionals.

Impact on the Real Estate Market

Rising insurance costs can limit homeownership opportunities and increase the overall cost of living. This is especially significant in areas like Port St. Lucie and other parts of the Treasure Coast, where affordability is a key concern for buyers.

  • Insurance premiums add to monthly housing expenses.
  • High costs may deter new buyers or force residents to reconsider homeownership.
  • Affordability issues are not limited to coastal cities but affect communities statewide.

Affordable States for Homeowners Insurance

While Florida leads in high premiums, some states offer much lower costs. According to realtor.com, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Vermont, and New Hampshire are among the most affordable, with annual rates between $800 and $1,500.

National Perspective

States with lower disaster risk and less exposure to extreme weather tend to have lower insurance premiums. This contrast highlights the impact of geography and climate on insurance markets nationwide.

Frequently Asked Questions About Florida Homeowners Insurance

What is the average cost of homeowners insurance in Florida?

According to realtor.com, Florida has the highest median homeowners insurance premiums in the United States, with many residents paying over $4,000 per year. This is significantly higher than the national average.

Why is homeowners insurance so expensive in Florida?

Florida’s high insurance costs are mainly due to its risk of hurricanes, flooding, and other severe weather events. The state’s legal environment has also contributed to higher premiums, according to official sources.

Are there affordable retirement communities with lower insurance in Port St. Lucie?

While Port St. Lucie offers a range of retirement communities, insurance costs remain high throughout Florida. Premiums may vary by location, but the statewide average is among the highest in the country.

Can you lower your homeowners insurance premium in PSL?

Homeowners in PSL can sometimes reduce premiums by improving home safety features, shopping for different policies, or increasing deductibles. However, overall rates in Florida remain high compared to other states.

Where are the lowest homeowners insurance rates in the U.S.?

States like Ohio, Pennsylvania, Vermont, and New Hampshire have some of the lowest homeowners insurance rates, with annual premiums between $800 and $1,500, according to realtor.com.

Port St Lucie Talks

Related News

Video News St. Lucie County

Local News

Crime & Public Safety

Politics & Government

Real Estate & Housing

Florida homeowners review home insurance documents amid rising premiums and market uncertainty.

Home Insurance Concerns Reshape Florida Real Estate Market

Aerial view of Port St. Lucie neighborhood showing homes affected by rising property taxes in 2025.

Port St. Lucie Property Taxes Rise Despite Millage Rate Cut

Map showing Florida as the most expensive state for homeowners insurance premiums

Florida Ranks Most Expensive for Homeowners Insurance

Infographic showing $1,500 rent square footage across Treasure Coast cities

$1,500 Rent Value Varies Across Treasure Coast Cities

Aerial view of Port St. Lucie showing vibrant homes and neighborhoods ranked best real estate market in Florida 2025.

Port St. Lucie Ranks Best Real Estate Market in Florida for 2025

Aerial view of Port St. Lucie, Florida, highlighting real estate market ranking 2025

Port St. Lucie Best Real Estate Market in Florida for 2025

VIRAL News

Transportation & Infrastructure