Florida home and auto insurance rates have surged dramatically since 2020, placing a significant financial strain on residents and prompting state officials to take action. The spike in insurance costs has made Florida one of the most expensive states for both homeowners and drivers, according to recent industry analyses.
Florida Home, Auto Insurance Rates See Unprecedented Increases
Both home and auto insurance rates in Florida have risen sharply over the past five years. According to an analysis by The Wall Street Journal, homeowners insurance rates in Florida have increased between 50% and 75%, while auto insurance rates have climbed 50% to 63% since 2020. These increases outpace the national average and far exceed the 26% rise in consumer prices reported by S&P Global Market Intelligence and the U.S. Department of Labor through August 2025.
For comparison, the national average for homeowners insurance rose by 50%, and auto insurance increased by 42% over the same period. Many Florida residents have reported difficulty finding affordable coverage, especially after multiple hurricanes caused extensive property damage in recent years. In light of these challenges, recent Florida home insurance rate changes and the upcoming hurricane season are being closely monitored by both consumers and industry experts.
Factors Driving Insurance Rate Hikes in Florida
Several factors have contributed to the rising cost of home and auto insurance in Florida. The state has experienced billions of dollars in insured losses from major hurricanes, including Irma, Michael, Ida, and Francine. These disasters have led insurers to increase premiums to cover growing risks and losses.
Additionally, the insurance market in Florida faces challenges from litigation costs and reinsurance expenses. According to the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC), these pressures have made it difficult for insurers to maintain profitability without raising rates.
Impact of Hurricanes and Severe Weather
Florida’s vulnerability to hurricanes and severe weather events is a key reason for escalating insurance rates. The frequency and severity of storms have resulted in higher claims and greater financial exposure for insurers. Officials report that the aftermath of recent hurricanes has led to billions in claims, further stressing the insurance market.
Litigation and Reinsurance Costs
Legal expenses and the cost of reinsurance—insurance that insurers buy to protect themselves—have also driven up premiums. According to the NAIC, Florida has one of the highest rates of insurance-related litigation in the country, which increases operating costs for insurance companies and is reflected in higher consumer premiums.
State and Federal Regulatory Responses
The steep increase in Florida home and auto insurance rates has sparked bipartisan concern among lawmakers. Both Democratic and Republican officials are under pressure to address affordability and access to essential insurance coverage.
According to the NAIC, all states except Wyoming require insurers to file notice of rate increases. In some states, including New Jersey and Pennsylvania, lawmakers have the authority to reject proposed increases. In Florida, regulatory oversight has focused on encouraging competition and reforming litigation practices.
Governor DeSantis Announces Insurance Relief Measures
On October 22, 2025, Governor Ron DeSantis announced that Florida residents would receive $1 billion in auto insurance refunds, citing recent reform laws, reduced litigation, and the entry of new insurers into the market. “This year, Florida’s top five auto insurers are averaging over a 6% rate reduction, and we’ve secured nearly $1 billion in credits for Progressive auto policyholders – and the other carriers are expected to follow suit soon,” DeSantis stated, according to the governor’s office.
The governor’s office also reported that 17 new insurance companies have entered Florida’s property insurance market, bringing more than $574 million in policyholder surplus. Since January 2024, 33 companies have filed for homeowners insurance rate decreases, and 46 have requested no change or an increase. Notably, Florida Peninsula Insurance proposes a historic rate cut for homeowners, signaling a potential shift in the market for property insurance.
Auto Insurance Rate Trends
For 2025, Florida’s top five auto insurance groups are indicating an average 6.5% rate decrease, following an average 4.3% increase in 2024 and a 31.7% increase in 2023. Officials attribute these improvements to market reforms and increased competition among insurers.
Industry Perspectives on Rate Controls
While many consumers support legislative efforts to cap insurance rates, industry analysts warn of potential drawbacks. Tim Zawacki, an analyst at S&P Global, told The Wall Street Journal that “price controls don’t lead to affordability. Ultimately, they just chase insurers out of the market.” Insurers argue that strict rate caps could reduce the availability of insurance and limit consumer choice.
Regulators in California recently approved double-digit increases in home insurance rates after major insurers threatened to leave the market. For years, California maintained a 6.9% cap on homeowner premium increases, but mounting wildfire risks and insurer losses have forced changes to this policy, resulting in higher rates for residents.
Recent Developments in Florida Insurance Market
Florida Peninsula Insurance Company, one of the state’s largest insurers, has requested its largest rate decrease in company history, averaging an 8.4% decrease statewide, according to the governor’s office. Domestic property insurers in Florida reported $954 million in net income at the end of 2024, up from $292 million in 2023 and reversing a $741 million loss in 2022. This remarkable turnaround is part of a broader trend, as property insurance companies in Florida see profits surge after years of financial struggle.
Officials say that these positive financial results and increased insurer participation are beginning to provide relief to Florida homeowners and drivers. However, many residents continue to face higher premiums than the national average, and the market remains sensitive to future weather events and economic changes.
Legislative Actions in Other States
Other states are also considering new regulations to address rising insurance costs. Pending legislation in Illinois would give the state’s insurance commission veto power over excessive rate increases. In Michigan, lawmakers have proposed a law to cut auto insurance rates by 10%. New York legislators are reviewing options to address soaring home insurance premiums.
These efforts reflect a nationwide concern about the affordability and accessibility of home and auto insurance, with each state pursuing different strategies based on local conditions and market dynamics.
Frequently Asked Questions About Florida Home, Auto Insurance Rates
What is causing Florida home and auto insurance rates to rise?
Insurance rates in Florida are rising due to hurricane damage, high litigation costs, and increased reinsurance expenses. These factors make it more expensive for insurers to operate in the state, leading to higher premiums for residents.
How much have home and auto insurance rates increased in Florida?
Since 2020, Florida homeowners insurance rates have increased by 50% to 75%, and auto insurance rates have risen 50% to 63%, according to industry reports. These increases are among the highest in the United States.
Are there any efforts to lower insurance rates in Florida?
Yes, state officials have enacted reforms and encouraged new insurers to enter the market. According to the governor’s office, 17 new companies have joined the property insurance sector, and some insurers are now filing for rate decreases.
Can you get refunds or credits on auto insurance in Florida?
Governor DeSantis announced that Florida residents will receive nearly $1 billion in auto insurance refunds and credits due to recent reforms. Progressive policyholders are among those expected to benefit, with other insurers likely to follow.
Where are Florida insurance rates compared to the national average?
Florida home and auto insurance rates are higher than the national average. The state’s unique risks, such as hurricanes, contribute to these elevated costs, making coverage more expensive for many residents.
Port St Lucie Talks
