Eriese Tisdale has been sentenced to death once again for the murder of St. Lucie County Sheriff’s Sgt. Gary Morales. This marks the second time Tisdale has received capital punishment for the crime, following the initial sentencing in 2016, which was later overturned due to changes in Florida’s sentencing laws.
Details of the Crime and Initial Sentencing
The incident occurred in 2013 when Sgt. Morales was fatally shot while conducting a routine traffic stop in St. Lucie County. Morales was found deceased in his patrol vehicle, prompting an intense investigation and subsequent arrest of Tisdale. Initially sentenced to death in 2016, Tisdale’s sentence was overturned after Florida law changed, requiring a unanimous jury vote for capital punishment.
Recent Jury Decision and Final Sentencing
Following the revised sentencing guidelines, a new jury deliberated and voted 9 to 3 in favor of the death penalty in September 2024. This majority vote met the current state requirement of at least an 8 to 4 jury recommendation for a death sentence. Consequently, Circuit Judge Lawrence Mirman formally sentenced Tisdale to death on March 10, 2025.
Current Death Row Statistics in Florida
According to the Florida Department of Corrections, there are currently 276 inmates on death row statewide. Tisdale joins several other inmates from the Treasure Coast region, including:
- Matthew Marshall, 60
- Billy Kearse, 51
- Lenard J. Philmore, 48
- Anthony Spann, 51
- William Reaves, 76
- Harold Harvey, 62
- Rodney Lowe, 54
Historical Context of Executions on the Treasure Coast
The most recent execution involving a Treasure Coast inmate was James Dennis Ford, who was executed on February 13, 2025, for the 1997 murders of a couple in Punta Gorda. Historically, five Treasure Coast inmates have been executed since 1939, including:
- David Alan Gore, 58, executed on April 12, 2012
- John Earl Bush, 38, executed on October 21, 1996
- James Adams, 47, executed on May 10, 1984
- Lacy Stewart, 17, executed on October 25, 1948
- Johnny Smith, 30, executed on May 12, 1939
Community Response and Next Steps
The sentencing has drawn significant attention from the local community, law enforcement agencies, and victim advocacy groups. Authorities continue to emphasize the importance of justice and closure for the family of Sgt. Morales. Readers are encouraged to share their thoughts and reactions to this sentencing decision in the comments below and on social media platforms.
Port St Lucie Talks
