Climate change is driving home insurance turmoil in Florida, with rising costs, shrinking coverage, and mounting challenges for homeowners in coastal and inland communities alike. As hurricanes, floods, and wildfires become more frequent and severe, insurers are facing unprecedented financial strain, leading to higher premiums, policy cancellations, and a shifting real estate landscape.

How Climate Change Is Driving Home Insurance Turmoil in Florida

For decades, areas like Sanibel Island on Florida’s Gulf Coast were considered low-risk by insurers. According to historical data, residents paid into their home and flood insurance policies year after year, rarely filing claims. Insurers collected significantly more in premiums than they paid out, making these regions profitable for the industry.

However, the situation changed dramatically after a series of devastating hurricanes. In September 2022, Hurricane Ian, a Category 4 storm, brought up to 12 feet of storm surge to Sanibel Island, flooding thousands of homes and damaging critical infrastructure. Two more hurricanes, Helene and Milton, struck in 2024, compounding the destruction and financial losses.

Impact of Recent Hurricanes on Florida Homeowners

According to the National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP), Hurricane Ian alone resulted in $620 million in flood insurance claims on Sanibel Island—nearly 100 times the total paid out over the previous 40 years. Neighboring communities such as Fort Myers Beach, Cape Coral, and Punta Gorda received over $1 billion in flood payouts. Property insurers covering wind and other damages paid billions more, making Ian one of the costliest hurricanes in history.

Officials reported that, despite efforts to limit development and protect natural areas, many homes on Sanibel remain just a few feet above sea level and are highly vulnerable to flooding. Older homes at ground level suffered the most damage, accounting for about 70 percent of the flood losses during Hurricane Ian, according to NFIP data.

Insurance Market Strain and Industry Response

The surge in climate-fueled disasters has placed the insurance industry under severe pressure. Analysts and former regulators warn that the traditional models used by insurers—based on stable, predictable climates—are no longer effective. As a result, insurers are reevaluating their exposure and, in many cases, withdrawing from high-risk markets.

Insurer Withdrawals and Policy Cancellations

According to industry reports, dozens of insurers in Florida, Louisiana, Texas, and California have either collapsed or been declared insolvent after catastrophic losses from hurricanes and wildfires. Major national companies, including Progressive, Allstate, and State Farm, have reduced their presence in high-risk states or stopped writing new policies altogether.

Between 2018 and 2023, insurers canceled nearly 2 million homeowner’s policies in response to rising climate risks—over four times the number typically expected in a single year. Many cancellations occurred with little warning, leaving homeowners scrambling to find alternative coverage, often at much higher prices. In recent years, property insurance companies in Florida have reported a surge in profits despite the turmoil, reflecting shifting market dynamics and the impact of premium hikes.

Rising Premiums and Affordability Concerns

Florida now has the highest rates of non-renewals and some of the most expensive home insurance premiums in the United States. According to data prepared by the U.S. Senate Budget Committee, the average cost of a homeowner’s policy nationally has risen by 30 to 40 percent in the past five years. In Florida, the average premium increased by $1,450 between 2020 and 2023, with some homeowners paying up to four times the national average.

Deductibles have also increased, adding to the financial burden for residents. The combination of higher premiums and deductibles is making insurance unaffordable for many, especially those on fixed incomes or with properties in high-risk areas.

State and Federal Responses to the Insurance Crisis

In response to market instability, Florida established the Citizens Property Insurance Corporation in 1992 as an insurer of last resort. While never intended to compete with private insurers, Citizens has grown to cover as many as 1.4 million policies at its peak. After Hurricane Ian, Citizens began reducing its exposure by transferring policies back to smaller private insurers.

Over 30 states have created similar state-backed insurance plans, known as FAIR plans, to fill gaps left by private companies. However, these plans often come with higher rates and concerns about their ability to cover catastrophic losses. For example, Louisiana raised its FAIR plan rates by over 60 percent following successive hurricanes in 2023.

Federal Flood Insurance Program Under Strain

The National Flood Insurance Program has also faced significant challenges. According to official sources, the NFIP is currently about $20 billion in debt to the U.S. Treasury, even after a $16 billion debt forgiveness. Recent premium increases are expected to double the average policy cost within five years, leading tens of thousands of homeowners to cancel their coverage.

Some analysts believe the federal government may need to intervene further to stabilize the market, as it did when creating the NFIP after private insurers withdrew from the flood insurance market decades ago.

Effects on Florida’s Housing Market

The insurance crisis is having a direct impact on Florida’s real estate market. Rising costs and limited availability of insurance are dampening demand for homes, especially in coastal floodplains and other high-risk areas. According to economists, potential buyers are now factoring insurance premiums, climate risks, and future storms into their purchasing decisions.

• On Sanibel Island, dozens of homes and condominiums have remained unsold for months or longer.
• Real estate agents report that there are now thousands of properties for sale in areas like Fort Myers and Cape Coral, compared to just a few dozen five years ago.
• Owners are offering significant discounts, sometimes up to $100,000, to attract buyers.

During the COVID-19 pandemic, demand for Florida homes soared, driving the median sales price on Sanibel to $1.3 million. Since then, prices have fallen back to pre-pandemic levels, reflecting the new realities of climate risk and insurance costs. In a rare positive development, Florida Peninsula Insurance has proposed a historic rate cut for homeowners, offering some hope for relief in a market otherwise dominated by rising premiums.

Home Elevation and Mitigation Efforts

Under the NFIP’s 50 percent rule, homes damaged by more than half their market value must be elevated to maintain flood insurance eligibility. However, some homeowners have avoided this requirement by obtaining new, higher property assessments. Others have sought state grants to help cover the high cost of elevating homes, which can range from $100,000 to $200,000. Funding for these programs is limited, and not all applicants are successful.

According to official sources, thousands of homes on Sanibel have been repaired since Hurricane Ian, but many remain at risk due to their low elevation. The ongoing threat of hurricanes and flooding continues to shape the decisions of homeowners and buyers alike.

Broader Implications for Florida and Beyond

Florida’s experience is part of a larger trend affecting high-risk regions across the United States. Since 2000, Florida has experienced 36 presidential disaster declarations, with damages exceeding $300 billion in the last seven years alone, according to the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA). Florida, Louisiana, and Texas account for about two-thirds of all hurricane and flood losses nationwide.

As climate change accelerates, the risks associated with natural disasters are expected to increase further. Experts warn that insurance affordability and availability will remain major challenges for homeowners, especially in coastal and flood-prone areas.

Frequently Asked Questions About Climate Change and Home Insurance Turmoil

What is driving the home insurance crisis in Florida?

Climate change is causing more frequent and severe hurricanes, floods, and wildfires. This leads to higher insurance claims and financial losses, making it harder for insurers to offer affordable coverage in Florida.

How much have home insurance premiums increased in Florida?

According to official sources, average home insurance premiums in Florida have risen by $1,450 between 2020 and 2023. Some homeowners now pay up to four times the national average.

Are there alternatives if private insurers cancel my policy?

Florida residents may be able to get coverage through Citizens Property Insurance Corporation, the state’s insurer of last resort. However, these policies often come with higher rates and deductibles.

Can you still get flood insurance in high-risk areas?

Flood insurance is available through the National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP), but premiums are rising and some homeowners are dropping coverage due to cost. Eligibility may also depend on meeting certain building requirements.

Where are the highest risks for home insurance turmoil in Florida?

Coastal areas like Sanibel Island, Fort Myers Beach, and Cape Coral face the highest risks due to their exposure to hurricanes and flooding. Inland areas are also seeing increased premiums as climate risks spread.

Port St Lucie Talks