Maggie McFly’s, a Connecticut-based restaurant chain known for its wide-ranging menu of American, Italian, and Tex-Mex cuisine, will open its second Florida location in Port St. Lucie, replacing the long-standing Bonefish Mac’s Sports Grille at 662 S.E. Becker Road. The new restaurant is scheduled to open in summer 2026, marking a significant addition to the local dining scene and contributing to the exciting developments boosting Port St. Lucie nightlife.

Maggie McFly’s Expands to Port St. Lucie

Founded in 1993 in Middlebury, Connecticut by Ray Harper, Maggie McFly’s has grown from a regional favorite to a national chain with locations in Connecticut, New York, Virginia, and Florida. According to the company’s website, the Port St. Lucie restaurant will become its tenth in the United States and its second in Florida, following the Boca Raton location.

The chain is recognized for its commitment to using fresh, locally sourced ingredients and offering a scratch-made menu. Maggie McFly’s aims to provide a unique dining experience with a “fine-casual” atmosphere and a lively bar, while maintaining a strong focus on food quality.

Menu Highlights at Maggie McFly’s Port St. Lucie

Maggie McFly’s menu features approximately 180 items, spanning American classics, Italian favorites, Tex-Mex dishes, Asian-inspired options, and more. The restaurant is known for its creative appetizers, hearty entrees, and indulgent desserts. If you’re a fan of smoked meats and savory flavors, you might also enjoy exploring the top barbecue restaurants in Port St. Lucie for even more local dining options.

• Big Mac Eggrolls: Ground beef, cheddar jack cheese, American cheese, onions, pickles, and housemade thousand island sauce.
• Cajun Jambalaya: Sautéed shrimp, chicken, and hot sausage in a spicy Cajun sauce, served with basmati rice.
• Farm to Table Burger: Grass-fed beef, Gouda cheese, smoked bacon, bibb lettuce, tomato, pickles, and red onion on a potato bun.
• Shrimp and Scallops Alla Vodka: Penne pasta, sautéed scallops and shrimp, vodka sauce, and asiago topping.
• Sriracha Burger: Maple smoked bacon, sriracha aioli, tomato, crumbled bleu cheese, fried jalapeños, pickles, red onion, and bibb lettuce on a potato bun.
• Desserts: Options include cheesecakes, sundaes, cupcakes, cakes, warm apple crisp, and “The Titanic”—a chocolate lava cake with ice cream, candy, and sauces.

The restaurant also offers gluten-sensitive and vegetarian-friendly dishes, as well as a variety of specialty cocktails and craft beers. Maggie McFly’s emphasizes sourcing ingredients from local vendors in each community it serves.

Bonefish Mac’s Sports Grille to Close After 17 Years

Bonefish Mac’s Sports Grille, a seafood and sports bar, has operated in Port St. Lucie for 17 years. According to restaurant manager Howard Fabian, the location will close on October 12, 2025, after its lease was not renewed. Fabian stated there are no plans to reopen on the Treasure Coast. Only two Bonefish Mac’s Sports Grille locations will remain in Florida, both in Broward County.

What Sets Maggie McFly’s Apart?

Maggie McFly’s distinguishes itself with its expansive, eclectic menu and dedication to local sourcing. The chain adapts its offerings to regional tastes and partners with local suppliers whenever possible. Community involvement is a core part of its business model, supporting local events and initiatives in each city it enters. The arrival of new restaurants, including recent additions like Del Taco’s first Port St. Lucie location, reflects the city’s growing appeal as a dining destination.

The Port St. Lucie location is expected to follow this model, bringing new dining options and community partnerships to the area. With a focus on quality, variety, and local engagement, Maggie McFly’s aims to become a destination for residents and visitors alike.

Frequently Asked Questions About Maggie McFly’s Port St. Lucie

What is Maggie McFly’s?

Maggie McFly’s is a restaurant chain founded in Connecticut, offering a large menu of American, Italian, Tex-Mex, and Asian dishes. It focuses on fresh, locally sourced ingredients and a scratch-made approach to food.

When will Maggie McFly’s open in Port St. Lucie?

According to Maggie McFly’s, the Port St. Lucie location at 662 S.E. Becker Road is scheduled to open in summer 2026.

What types of food does Maggie McFly’s serve?

The menu includes American classics, Italian favorites, Tex-Mex options, Asian-inspired dishes, and specialty desserts. There are also choices for gluten-sensitive and vegetarian diners.

Where is Maggie McFly’s replacing Bonefish Mac’s Sports Grille?

Maggie McFly’s will open at 662 S.E. Becker Road in The Shoppes at Veranda Falls, taking over the space currently occupied by Bonefish Mac’s Sports Grille in Port St. Lucie.

Are there other Maggie McFly’s locations in Florida?

Yes, Maggie McFly’s currently has one Florida location in Boca Raton. The Port St. Lucie restaurant will be its second in the state.

Port St Lucie Talks